← Back to Forum
Land Buying1 min read

Leasing First Changed What I'd Buy Outright Forever

?
Addie Farren
2 days, 4 hours ago
👁 8 views💬 2 replies
Three years into leasing five acres, I've completely reversed my thinking on the popular advice to 'buy as soon as you can afford anything.' I used to treat leasing as a consolation prize — something you did while saving for the real thing. Now I think leasing first is genuinely the smarter path, especially for first-gen folks with no farming background. I've learned what soil problems I can actually tolerate, what road access situations drive me insane, how important neighbor relationships are before you're locked in, and what 'enough land' even means for the way I actually farm — not the way I imagined I would farm. If I'd bought the first property I could technically afford, I would have bought wrong. Leasing gave me three years of real data about my own preferences and limits. The conventional wisdom treats buying as the obvious finish line. But I'd argue leasing is a research phase that most first-gen buyers skip at serious cost. Has anyone else leased before buying and found it shifted what you were even looking for?
#land leasing#first-generation homesteaders#land buying#rural land access#western North Carolina

Join the Discussion

2 Replies

?
Nora Casteel
1 day, 17 hours ago
You're right that leasing first teaches you things no amount of research can. But I'd push back on 'enough land' being something you can figure out in three years on five acres. Water rights don't reveal themselves that fast. I leased for four years before I understood the senior/junior rights situation on that ground — and that knowledge would have completely changed what I was willing to pay to own it.
?
Colt Waverly
1 day, 2 hours ago
Southwest Montana perspective here: I'd push back slightly. When stream-access rights and water shares are involved, leasing rarely teaches you what matters most. I leased along a spring creek for two seasons thinking I understood the water situation — then watched a downstream buyer lock up the senior water right before I could act. Leasing taught me the land. Didn't teach me what I'd lose by waiting. Know your water before you commit to anything.