I used to think a clean title and a good well were enough to greenlight a purchase. Then I bought an adjoining parcel without ordering a hydrogeological assessment, assuming the aquifer behavior would mirror my existing land. It didn't. The new parcel sat over a different limestone formation with almost no lateral connectivity to the productive zone my existing wells drew from. Drilled two wells. Both marginal. That land cost me four years of hauling water.
Everybody talks about well logs, and yes, review them. But a historic well log tells you what was there when it was drilled — not the formation structure, not recharge rates, not how neighboring pumping affects your zone. In karst terrain especially, you can be two hundred yards from a productive well and hit nothing.
A hydrogeological site assessment isn't cheap, but it's cheaper than a dry well and cheaper than buying land that can't support your intended use.
I'd argue geology due diligence is more important than surface water rights in many parts of the arid Southwest and Hill Country. Anyone in a different geology — say, glacial aquifer country in the Midwest — find that surface indicators actually predicted well performance reliably?